(idm) It's not whether you suck; it's how well

From Mitchell K. Hilton
Sent Fri, Jul 10th 1998, 19:11

>> Organic sucks.

*Real* instruments suck.

Vocals suck.

Live sucks.

If you want all that, listen to folk music. Give me the cold, hard, &
artificial, baby. <<

</lurk>

I *hope* you're taking the piss.  Does Squarepusher suck because he =
plays live bass?  What does it mean when one likes both electronic and =
acoustic music?  My CD wallet currently contains Harry Smith's =
_Anthology of American Folk Music_ as well as a fistful of electronic =
CD's of various flavors, and stuff I'm almost embarrassed to mention, =
like Elvis and Chumbawamba's _Swingin' With Raymond_.  What would you =
say if I stuck the lot in a blender and hit "puree"?  Bwahaha!  Oh damn, =
wait, Beck and the aforementioned Chumbas already did that.  ;)

Me, I like just about anything done well in the service of a specific =
artistic vision.  Except opera.  And I may yet discover an opera =
composer who blows my mind.  As for the sampling debate, I'm reminded of =
Marcel Duchamp with his urinal and his mustachioed Mona Lisa.  Was he an =
artist or a charlatan?  Time has proven one can be both, 'cause he was.  =
Which in turn reminds me of AFX.

Oh well, I guess one man's eclectism is another's dilettantism.  Or =
maybe at 31 I've outgrown believing that the music I listen to dictates =
who I am and the lifestyle I am supposed to lead.  Or maybe I've seen =
too many promising musical movements die of inbreeding.  <sarcasm>  Or =
maybe I should just shut my piehole, 'cause I'm only on this list to try =
and complete my AFX collection anyway.  </sarcasm>

Sorry if this ground has been covered already.  I have been away for a =
couple of days and I have a buttload of email left to go through.

Peace,
Mitch

PS:  Respect to the guy who name-dropped Joe Jackson.  His _Will Power_ =
is a brilliant 'modern classical' album often found in cutout bins (at =
least in America).  Don't listen to "No Pasaran" for the first time with =
a hot cup of coffee in your hand though, it *will* end up all over you.

Now playing:  V/A, _Avantgardism Drum 'n' Bass_

<lurk>