Re: (idm) punk [cough cough]

From TheevilD
Sent Mon, Sep 13th 1999, 17:57

> Hey, you who refuses to name him/herself:
> Punk is one of the most conservative _musical_
> genres ever. How many punk albums do you still 
> listen to? If it's more than 5, then you're
> a sad individual. Prog rock, despite being nearly
> universally reviled (usually by
> people who've barely heard the music), is
> a helluva lot more sonically interesting than
> punk ever was (give me Gong's _You_ over _Never
> Mind The Bollocks_ any day).

Punk gave us three things:
1) You don't need to sign to a big label and go the corporate route.
2) Energy and feeling are more inportant than technical difficulty
3) Anyone can make music
These are the basic ideas that have informed most good forms of music ever 
since (including idm). Warp records were born out of a classic DIY punk 
approach.
Prog said pretty much the opposite.
Anyhow, psychedelia's blatantly prog without the crap bits, and is a lot more 
innaresting.

Any arguments?

jorkens