(idm) Re: idm-digest V2 #779

From nils
Sent Tue, Jul 20th 1999, 18:08

<xxxxxxxxxx_xxxxxxxxx@xxxx.xxxxxx.xxx> wrote:

> Did any of you check out the quality of the various brands of CDs that are
> available to make audio copies?
>
> I made an audio copy on a MAXWELL CD at the end of May.  And over the
> week-end, when I wanted to listen to it, my CD player did not recognized it
> at all.
>
> A friend of mine told me  that MAXELL has the worst CDs to make audio
> copies.  Supposedly, VERBATIM also give suboptimal quality.

funny that you say that, maxell is my stock blank.  i think you had a
random problem not specific to the media.  all cd-r's appear to track
slower, but i've never had one be unrecognizable.

i recommend trying a comparison yourself, as i did with about 10 brands.

the results of my survey (two-observer, double-blind):

maxell the best
sony (two varietites) very good
memorex okay
verbatim & fuji abominable

differences between brands manifested themselves as a loss of detail,
primarily.  not related to tracking.

you should definitely consider writing at a slower speed for higher
audio fidelity.  i found a monstrous difference between 4x and 2x write
speeds, but very little difference between 2x and 1x write speeds.

n