Re: (idm) WARP,MP3LEECHEZ & FAIR PLAY

From the Quaternions
Sent Fri, Apr 16th 1999, 23:52

> 
> Portishead's "PNYC" and the Counting Crows double-live album were both in
> response to haeavy bootlegging of those specific shows, although they
> weren't widely available on mp3, they were probably just several months
> from that.

As far as I know, the Portishead show was a one-off specifically set up to
be recorded for future release. That's what my friend who was there said.
I'd assume that regarding the bootlegging of live shows, it helps those
groups whose shows are based on "jamming", like Phish, or maybe even
Autchre, by helping to build a dedicated live fanbase.  Of course, those
groups have to tour constantly to fulfill their end of the bargain.
        Probably, groups like Portishead are hurt by bottlegging, b/c
they're sets are similar every time--a dedicated groups will attend
multiple show, but the appeal isn't there for the casual fan. If their
older shows were bootlegged, it probably indicated to their label that an
interest existed, but it also cut into sales of the live release.