Re: (idm) mp3s of the peel sessions and others...

From Bryan Campbell
Sent Mon, Sep 13th 1999, 18:43

At 8:47 AM -0700 9/13/99, Sam Stein wrote:
>as for all of those that are opposed to the ethics of
>mp3s and all that stuff, what are your views on the
>mp3s of a peel session? are they legal?


My opinion is that if it's made from the original broadcast, no problem. If
however, it's made from the digital recording (released on CD), then
there's some question.

Personally, I'd rather buy a CD than download an mp3. Differences in mp3
encoding algorithms, and settings, can be likened to the difference between
crappy and pro-quality tape recorders. And I'm not willing to rely on
joe-internet-six-pack's opinion of what "acceptable sound quality" is. ;-)


b.