Re: (idm) Reynolds etc.

From Tom Millar
Sent Fri, Apr 9th 1999, 22:34

Sean Cooper wrote:

> as an alternative to reynolds' all-too-ideological line of thought, i'd
> suggest sarah thornton's "club cultures" (wesleyan, 1996), which aims to
> understand the internal logics of subcultural forms and their situation
> in/relationship to the larger divisions out of which they grow, through
> which they are articulated, and with which they are in inevitabe dialogue.

That's all well and good and I realize that baseline analytical methods are
truly at the heart of many of such communicative disagreements, but it changes
nothing about the fact the lo-fi nerd-ness and the techno variety of this
disease which many people on this list apparently possess is self-destructive
and does little to truly help art.

I have no problem with the pragmatic issues involved in the pressing-of-500
practice employed my so many, but the whole extra-limited-edition "look at how
exclusive my stuff is" shit doesn't mean anything really. It doesn't add real
value to art when you purposefully make it obscure. If you have to start small
and only press 500, that's an important consideration, but if you make enough
money and have enough demand to do a repressing, do it, don't say "well, I'm
going to make this a limited edition, so sorry." That's crap.

Tom