Re: (idm) Judge bans digital music device

From Lazlo Nibble
Sent Tue, Oct 20th 1998, 00:08

On Mon, Oct 19, 1998 at 03:16:51PM -0700, Jeremy Wells wrote:

> The ridiculousness of this ban comes to light when you realize that a
> portable laptop or even a handheld computing device that can play back
> MP3 files does not violate any laws, yet is nearly identical to the
> Diamond player.

The law in question only applies to devices that are primarily used for music
recording and playback.  The Rio qualifies; handhelds and laptops don't.

> The RIAA, BMI, and ASCAP were created for the greedy by the greedy and
> designed to screw the little guy.

<shrug> No argument there, but Diamond knew they were gambling on the law
being interpreted in their favor.  When you gamble, sometimes you lose.

-- 
Lazlo Nibble                        |  "There's no moral, Uncle Remus, just
xxxxx@xxxx.xxx                        |   random acts of meaningless violence."
http://www.swcp.com/lazlo        |                -- Michael O'Donoghue