Re: (idm) Freeform

From Peter Hollo
Sent Sat, Aug 21st 1999, 03:18

Konstantin Minko wrote:
>Could anyone help me to decide if I should by any other albums by 
> Freeform if I'm crazy about "Pattern Tub"?

Pattern Tub's the only one I like. If you're CRAZY about Pattern Tub
you'll probably like others, but I find the rhythms very annoying, sort
of stilted and un-funky, although they're more like "funk" or whatever
than the drum'n'bass, dub or hip hop kind of rhythms I like more myself.

Roy G Biv wrote:
> Basically Freeform is pretty damn cool, i like the jazzy syncopation 
> he puts into all his beats and melodies, plus the fact that he's into 
> doing melodic solos/improvs over his loops, kinda like jake 
> slazenger...but not quite as tongue in cheek

For the sake of saying so, I think Freeform is consistently extremely
disappointing. Some of the tracks on Pattern Tub are fantastic,
experimental, interestingly done etc. There's nothing as lovely as the
vocal sampling tracks from Pattern Tub on anything else he's released.

Elastic Speakers, from 1995, is all synths and those same rhythms I
can't get into. Yes, the melodies recall Jake Slazenger in part, and
aren't as tongue in cheek but still terribly cheesy. I LOVE Mike P as
Mu-ziq, Tusken Raiders and Kid Spatula, but Jake Slazenger seems a waste
of time to me. I think it's that electro thing somehow...
The "jazzy syncopations" are just lame to me, they don't move me or
interest me conceptually. As opposed to say Mu-ziq or Jake Mandell,
whose rhythms and weird melodies/harmonies are much better IMHO.

As usual, this is only my opinion, and many people clearly think
Freeform's great. I've attempted to explain why I don't, so that those
who perhaps share my taste can know to at least give it a listen first.
Cheers,
Peter.
-- 
Peter Hollo  xxxxx@xxxxxxxx.xxx.xx  http://www.fourplay.com.au/me.html
              FourPlay - Eclectic Electric String Quartet
                       http://www.fourplay.com.au
                     Raven: experimental electronic
                 http://www.fourplay.com.au/sound.html
"Of course, dance music can be a music where you lie on your back and
your brain cells dance" -Michael Karoli of Can, quoted in Wire mag.