Re: (idm) budakhan mindphone - one more perspective

From Kent Williams
Sent Sun, Mar 7th 1999, 18:37

On Sun, 7 Mar 1999, Rodney Perkins wrote:

> As was the case with "Music is Rotted One Note", this is pretty good. 
> However, if I was neophyte who had never heard any other Squarepusher
> release, I'd probably wouldn't even give it a second listen.
> 
With some musicians, they give you the sinse tops. Guys like Squarepusher
give you the tops, shwag, sticks, stems, and seeds, and lets you sort it out.

There are things I like about  Budokan Mindphone -- the stuff with
breaks, and the gamelan piece at the end until I realized that the bass
wasn't ever going to drup, and it was just going to meander and then stop.

I also like that it came out domestic and I could get it for 8 bucks.

As someone who makes tracks, it sometimes seems like Warp and Rephlex
are going to release whatever DATs he throws at them unedited. I'd love
to be in that position, but on the other hand I'd hope someone would weed
out the wack tracks before enshrining them forever on CD. I can't imagine
someone at Warp listening to this record and saying WOW this is the shit!

Until and unless either TJ or his labels get serious about track selection,
they run the danger of seeming like they are just capitalizing on his
current noteriety,  and devaluing his very real merits by dilution.