Re: (idm) Carl Craig (Re: New Discoveries)

From Will Samuels
Sent Tue, Apr 20th 1999, 02:09

-- Che <xxxxx@xxxxxxxx.xxx> wrote:
> At 02:10 PM 4/14/99 -0700, Will Samuels wrote:
> 
> >A few people have dissed Landcruising on the list
> and
> >it's surprises me because it is an excellent cd. I
> >think the retro-ishness of the cd turned some
> people
> >off, but I think it gets better everytime I listen
> to
> >it. 
> 
> Cos it's fucking rock n'roll, and I HATE rock
> n'roll. Rock n'roll is for
> old people.

What the hell are you talking about? Just because a
electronic track might use minor amounts of guitar,
than it is rock n roll and therefore sucks

Man! And people think I am picky and critical. I
definitely think that you can still make great music
using keyboards, guitars, digeridoos, and 100s of
other instruments. As long as you use them in a
creative way (vs a cliche way).

> ;) Seriously, I like all of Carl's other work that
> I've heard.  He's
> written more than his share of bonafide Techno
> classics.  

Agreed

> But Landcruising made my skin crawl.  Guitar &
Techno > just don't mix, unless it's done
> really, really well, like on Scoobs In Columbia. 
> Most attempts just leave
> me sick to my stomach (no, I'm not exaggerating),
> including Landcruising.

Wow. we obviously disagree on that. I think
Landcruising is one of my all time favorite techno/idm
cds of all times. It's definitely up there with all
the old Aphex Twin and Autechre stuff.

So do you not like anything at all with guitars? I
can't stand most rock. I do really like stuff like My
Bloody Valentine, Flying Saucer Attack, Stereolab and
alot of stuff on the Kranky label.
 
_________________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com