(idm) in defense of richard thomas

From Sean Cooper
Sent Sun, Nov 9th 1997, 22:15

>described in the wire as 'the welsh sun-ra'[ahem], richard composes with out
>the aid of digital technology, just found sound, tape loops and ye old
>skool real live instrumentation, some inspired moments, comes on like ui
>meets throbbing gristle meets mantronix, but richard fails to stamp it
>with any
>mark of originality and the whole thing renders itself a composite of
>>previously visited and far superior musical vistas

well, probably i should just let my previous message do this for me, but
i'm so taken by the richard thomas ep above-slagged that i felt the need to
tackle it head-on.

to my ears, there are a few artists releasing music in the "electronica"
world giving a committed once-over to combining electronics and acoustics
in an experimental context both balanced and innovative. these include
david moufang, kreidler, mouse on mars, and bisk, and i would also include
richard thomas (at least what i've heard of him). the welsh sun ra is, of
course, typical wire hyberbole--insufficient, reductive, and ultimately
damaging, appealing to an ahistorically eclectic "avant-gardism" and
expressing little more than a vague similarity of enthusiasm in the writer
(i'm guilty of this all the time, so i know it when i see it). not all of
thomas' lo sampler hits with extreme force, but after listening to the
whole thing through for the third or fourth time straight, my lingering
impression was that it was some of the most *original* music to straddle
the range of genres it does.

so there. :p

sc

onnow: ground zero : null & void (tzadik)