Re: (idm) Poll Categories

From PLeXitMIND
Sent Wed, Dec 9th 1998, 04:18

In a message dated 12/9/98 4:36:40 AM Central Standard Time,
xxxxx@xxxxxxxxx.xxx writes:

<< >Most Anticipated LP/release for 1999
 
 I'm totally against this, because people necessarily will be voting without
 having heard what they're voting for. Whatever wins (hell, waterer's
 nominated) in this category will be listed on the mailing list homepage for
 years to come, even if it turns out to be a bad record. I don't want newbies
 buying records that turned out to be disappointments just because a lot of
 people were "anticipating" them around poll time.
  >>

Of course it is going to be albums nobody has heard yet; it goes with the
category.  Newbies will not buy the most anticipated albums.  Newbies are
going to buy the albums that win the 'best of..' categories.  Your reasons for
not having this category are illogical.  10 years from now I would like to be
able to go back and see that 'so and so' album was the most anticipated album
of 99, and whether or not the album turned out to be a classic or shite is
irrelevant.  It's all about what people couldn't wait to hear at that time.
Any newbie who starts buying 'most anticipated' albums isn't that bright to
begin with.  Logic dictates that a new person will buy what people recommend
and albums that win the 'best of awards'.


Thanks for the time.

Turk