Re: (idm) Reynolds' most overrated music of 1998 (IDM, anyone?)

From Tim Koch
Sent Fri, Apr 9th 1999, 02:58

Nothing against obscurity (that would really be the pot calling the kettle
black I suppose) or unusual formats/packaging, or coveting rare records. But
a lot of this geektronica stuff has crossed the line into wilful
obscurantism. With records coming out in pressings of 250 or even fifty
(with handpainted covers etc), you have to wonder what's the threshold below
which music ceases to be a "cultural practice" and becomes mere hobbyism? As
the phenomenon of music distributed through the Internet, downloaded and
CD-burned continues to develop, this global geektronic network may well
devolve into a barter economy, with bedroom producers trading their music
with other artists through the Net. Momus recently suggested that rather
than everybody being famous for 15 minutes, in the future everybody will be
famous for 15 people. That's what it's getting like, and that's why we
should be getting worried.


 for fucksake .. I used to collect NME's and Melody Maker's for 10
years (weekly UK music rags) and immediately switched off to
any of Mr.Reynold's dribblings .. so this thread surprises me ..
that the man is still eager to put down what he doesn't understand ..