Re: [AH] Nord Micro VS Doepfer VS MOTM VS ???

From improv
Sent Tue, Apr 6th 1999, 18:23

Thanks to everyone who voiced an opinion on this. I got a kick out of all
the metaphors, geez, some of you guys should be writing ad copy...

Anyway, yesterday I ordered a big pile of MOTM kits. As has been stated
many times on this list, Paul Schreiber is a great to do business with, he
took a lot of time out of his day to answer my questions over the phone,
and struck me as a totally committed and brilliant synth designer. I really
look forward to building his kits. It was interesting, most of the response
I got from my original post was from MOTM owners, nobody advised me to go
with the Nord. Not that that was all that made my decision, but it does
show how satisfied Paul's customers are.

I mainly decided to go with the MOTM modules over the Nord for a couple of
reasons. Firstly, I'm only using Mac's, and it seems that getting the Nord
to run under emulation is not a particularly easy task, and I have no space
to bring another computer into the studio. Next summer, if and when the Mac
editor is available, I might reconsider, but for now, this is a big
negative for the Nord.

Another point is that I think that there's something more that can be done
with the DSP power we have right now than emulate analog models. I'm no
analog purist, I have as much digital gear as analog, the DX-7 is the synth
I probably understand the deepest, and I have nothing against digital
sounds. In fact, I probably understand DSP stuff better than I do analog
circuitry, I could probably code a DSP oscillator, but there's no way I
could design an analog osc. That's part of the reason I'm getting the MOTM,
to learn more about analogs. I've been using MAX for years, and recently
got David Zicarelli's MSP audio extensions. While MAX/MSP is probably way
less intuitive than the Nord, and is also tied to the computer, it seems
like a more open space for developing new sounds than the Nord.

Anyway, thanks again to everyone who wrote, and I think I'll be spending
the next few weeks hunched over my soldering iron...

________________________________________________________
Dave Trenkel : xxxxxx@xxxx.xxx  : www.peak.org/~improv/

"...there will come a day when you won't have to use
gasoline. You'd simply take a cassette and put it in
your car, let it run. You'd have to have the proper
type of music. Like you take two sticks, put 'em
together, make fire. You take some notes and rub 'em
together - dum, dum, dum, dum - fire, cosmic fire."
                                            -Sun Ra
________________________________________________________