Re: [AH] Alternatives to the UM-880 USB-MIDI interface?

From Brian Willoughby
Sent Sat, Dec 22nd 2018, 06:26

On Dec 21, 2018, at 9:46 PM, codemechanic <xxxxxxxxxxxx@xxxxx.xxx> =
wrote:
> Two important things they do:
> - work without needing to be connected to a computer
> - support midi over ethernet (RTP Midi) - USB not required
>=20
> Here's more information on RTP Midi, aka AppleMIDI:
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RTP-MIDI
>=20
> RTP Midi has been around for many moons and was released as a part of
> Mac OS X v10.4 Tiger. There's an RFC for RTP Midi
> (https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6295), and it has support for both
> Midi timestamps and latency compensation. The wikipedia page states
> average latency of 1-2ms with the possibility of hitting 125
> microseconds under optimal conditions. Here is some additional
> information on RTP Midi in regards to latency:
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RTP-MIDI#Latency

Thanks!

Learning more about real-world use of RTP-MIDI has been on my to-do list =
for a while now. I plan to design RTP-MIDI into my next product. Sounds =
like it can outperform USB. Glad to read that you=E2=80=99re using it =
successfully.


> Back to the older USB units... I've run the Unitor 8 under Mac OS X
> Sierra and everything works fine (same with the MTP AV for that
> matter). The latest Unitor Family Driver 2.5 is still available on
> Apple's website. I can't recall the exact process but if you don't
> have it installed already and you launch Logic with your
> Unitor8/AMT8/MT4 interface plugged in, you should be prompted to
> download and install the 2.5 driver.
>=20
> Unitor Family Driver 2.5
> https://support.apple.com/kb/DL991

That sounds promising. If Apple are supporting it, then the driver =
probably supports the advanced features of CoreMIDI properly (no =
guarantees, of course, but it seems most likely).


> Most of the iConnectivity devices (PlayAUDIO12, MIDI4+, mio4, mio10)
> come equipped with a LAN port and support RTP Midi. Here's a some
> additional information:
> =
https://www.iconnectivity.com/blog/2018/3/1/midi-over-ethernet-the-marvel-=
of-rtp-midi
>=20
> And ofcourse there are tons of other implementations of RTP Midi under
> other OSes and languages including Linux, iOS, Arduino, etc.

Thanks again for the real-world examples of RTP MIDI in use.

Brian