(idm) re: The Rio MP3 player (fwd)

From Mark Kolmar
Sent Wed, Oct 21st 1998, 01:35

Rather than strangling someone at the RIAA, I wrote them this letter.
They are not protecting my interests, and very likely none of yours
either.

---------- Forwarded message ----------
Date: Mon, 12 Oct 1998 16:26:21 -0500 (CDT)
From: Mark Kolmar <xxxxxxx@xxxx.xxx>
To: xxxxxxxxx@xxxx.xxx
Subject: The Rio MP3 player

Please forward to appropriate people.

Gentlemen:

Once again you display your digital paranoia and your fundamental
misunderstanding of the role of home-taping in promoting awareness of
music, especially music by new and lesser-known artists.

The only important difference between analog and digital media with
respect to home-taping is generation loss.  I assure you that generation
loss is not a very significant deterrent.  (Note that you are up in arms
about a device which plays music recorded with a -lossy-, perceptual
encoding scheme.)

I shudder to think about the ways in which you ostensibly try to protect
my interests. First, your actions make it more difficult and expensive for
me, and artists like me, to record our music in the first place.  Second,
you wish to deter people from promoting awareness of our music in highly
effective ways. Third, your agenda funnels money away from lesser-known
artists, and into the pockets of better-known arists and their lawyers.  
Finally, you appear to operate under the false assumption that an
unauthorized copy represents a lost sale.  The reality, as you should
know, is much more complex.

Sincerely,

--Mark Kolmar

=-=-


__ Available now: SENSELESS CD on Mindfield Records MindCD03 Cathartium 14
   < Distributed by Dutch East India Trading and Carrot Top Distribution >
   < http://www.xnet.com/~mkolmar/BurningRome > < MP3 & RealAudio tracks >