Re: (idm) Re: IDM formulas?

From Brian Gingold
Sent Fri, Oct 17th 1997, 12:34

>Yes, part of the equation, but I just wanted to focus on RDJ's SAW#1 
>as the place where the formula all came together for what we call IDM. 
>(a mad scientist he is:)
>> >
>> > I don't know how to make the wicked sounds that Ae and the like do,
>> > but all these minimal IDM artists do follow a standard formula.
>> 
>read... MINIMAL IDM artists. Guess this formula only works with 
>minimal IDM tracks. stupid me....
>
>> except for The Black Dog, B12, Scala (not really minimal IDM I guess),
>> Mouse on Mars, Plug (the EP's at least), FSOL, Elfish Echo, Bisk, 


The music is not about a formula.  There may be common features to many
tracks, but this doesn't indicate that artists are just throwing sounds ad
hoc into a formula and pressing CDs.  You've picked out specific elements
of the songs that are common.  But even these individual elements vary
significantly.  And you're ignoring a great deal of the other aspects of
the music.
____________________________________________________________________________
Brian Gingold, University of California at Davis
"sound" - KDVS 90.3 FM  alternate Thursdays 12-3AM  ambient/experimental/idm
Web:  http://wwwcsif.cs.ucdavis.edu/~gingold