Re: [AH] Roland Boutique MIDI Chain Mode

From Brian Willoughby
Sent Fri, Jun 22nd 2018, 03:08

* Excellent description *


On Jun 16, 2018, at 5:21 PM, Florian Anwander <xxxxxxxxx@xxxx-xxxxxx.xx> =
wrote:
> Hello Tim
>=20
> I don't own a chainable boutique synth, so I can speak only from =
general knowhow. I'll answer first your questions, then I will get a =
little more elaborate:
> =20
>> 1. Do all units  in chain mode have to be on the same MIDI channel?
>>=20
> Yes
>=20
>>  2. If so, can multiple chains be set up on different channels =
(should I ever get more units to make this a thingJ?
>>=20
> Yes
>>=20
>>  3. Does chain mode have to be enabled on both master and slave, or =
just the master?
>>=20
> Only on the master (but see below)
>>=20
>>  4. If the slave doesn't need to be set for chain mode, are all =
downstream devices from the master automatically added to the chain, or =
is it just the immediate neighbour, or matching MIDI channel?
>>=20
> See below
>=20
>=20
> Now lets get a little elaborate:
>=20
> I do not like the expression "master" for a synth in chain mode. I'd =
prefer to say: "this synth is a chain maker".=20
>=20
> To understand chainmode we have to get away from the boutique series =
and we have to assume four voice synths which have separate sockets for =
MIDI-Out and MIDI-Thru (and MIDI-In ofcourse).  All synths are set to =
the same MIDI channel.
>=20
> We connect the MIDI-sequencer to MIDI-In of synth A and then we =
connect synth A's MIDI-Thru with MIDI-In of synth B. We send ten =
MIDI-Notes from the MIDI-sequencer: synth-A and synth-B both will     =
play the same four notes, and will not be able to play the other six =
remaining notes. That is because the classic MIDI-thru is basically a =
hardwired feedthru. It is like a multiple in a modular system. The =
microprocessor of the synth usually has no access to the MIDI-thru =
socket!
>=20
> No we rewire the MIDI connection between synth A and B: we connect =
A-out with B-in.
> Again we send ten MIDI-Notes from the MIDI-sequencer: synth-A will =
play four notes and synth-B will play ... nothing. Because the =
MIDI-input  is usually not available at the MIDI-out. The MIDI-out is =
fed by the microprocessor of the synth and usually only sends MIDI =
informations of notes and other events generated on the correspondings =
synth.
>=20
> Now we switch on the chain mode on synth A. This means the =
microprocessor decides, which notes it will play with his four voices, =
and which notes he will not play. The microprocessor will send those =
other notes to its MIDI-out.=20
> Now we have connected synth-B to this MIDI-out. For synth-B it will =
look like it is connected to a sequencer which sends six notes. Again it =
will not be able to play all six notes.
>=20
> But we could set synth-B also to chain mode and connect a synth-C to =
the MIDI-out of B. The microprocessor of B will decide which four notes =
will be played by own voices and will send the remaining two notes to =
its MIDI-out. There is synth-C connected, which will play the two notes.
> In theory you might connect 32 synths in chain mode and let them play =
all 128 possible midi notes at the same time.
>=20
>=20
> If we now get back to the Boutique series: those do not have a =
separate MIDI-thru socket. Instead the synths microprocessor forwards =
all incoming notes to the MIDI-out socket. This function is called "soft =
thru". In the chain mode this soft thru is modified. The microprocessor  =
will forward all incoming notes but will remove those notes from the =
stream which it is playing with his own four voices.
>=20
>=20
> I think this makes clear, why I don't like the term "master" in the =
context of chaining. There can be many chain-makers in a row. Only for =
the last synth in the row it is not relevant whether it runs in chain =
mode or not. But the setting of the last synth it is relevant for the =
chain, because it will be the last element in the chain.
>=20
>=20
>=20
> I hope that made it a little clearer.
>=20
> Florian