Re: (idm) Plaid - "Not For Threes"

From Michael Upton
Sent Sun, Nov 1st 1998, 22:40

On Sun, 1 Nov 1998, Che wrote:

| If it accomplishes anything, it proves that Warp fucked up bigtime in
| dropping Black Dog.  In 5 years, we'll still be talking about "Music For
| Adverts", while "Not For Threes" will be an album that you have trouble
| giving away.

I guess I still won't be listening then. It sounds
like I experience exactly the reverse of what you
do. I find 'Music for Adverts' so damn 
frustrating, and a completely soulless bunch of
ideas. Sure, it has ideas, not just rehash, but a
crap idea is a crap idea, and that's all I hear. 

I think Plaid's album is patchy, but there are
things on it that I'd consider listening to, which
puts it above 'Music for Adverts' to my ears.

It's also amusing that my flatmate would be
agreeing fully with Che if he was on here - this
seems to be quite a common disagreement between
fans of the older Black Dog. Well, actually both
of us like 'Spanners' most, so not that much
older BDP.

Michael

____________________________________________
"Also, he has automatic evasion devices"
http://www.vuw.ac.nz/~michael/jj.html