Re: [AH] Moog Prodigy 1:1 replica

From Oakley Sound via analogue
Sent Mon, Aug 20th 2018, 08:56

 > The seller kindly popped the hood and took some shots for me:
 > https://imgur.com/a/RZqdhwI

A few thoughts but not necessarily criticisms...

1. I can't see an earth connection. A decent IEC mains inlet would be 
preferable. And without an earth it's probably illegal to sell it.

2. Single sided circuit board like the original. Clearly made as a one 
off though. No solder mask like the original. But unlike the original, 
made from two boards which rely on a thick band of soldered copper 
between the two boards on the underside and several wire links on the 
topside. Bearing in mind that the pots aren't secured to the front panel 
the whole thing is probably quite flimsy.

3. I haven't worked out how those pots are secured. It looks like 
heatshrink tube over a cylindrical bit of wood/plastic with two bits of 
wire soldered to the pot body and into the board. Probably quite stable 
but must have taken ages to do.

4. The pots are for the most part 16mm Alpha or similar. I've never 
found Alpha's log pots that satisfactory for the EGs attack, decay and 
release pots because the taper law isn't accurate enough at the fast end.

5. Hefty power supply and, unlike the original, the electronics are not 
fitted to the main board which is probably a good thing. I would have 
mounted the power devices onto a slab of aluminium and secured to the 
rear panel getting the heat away from the insides. But as it stands I 
don't think they'd heat up that much anyhow.

6. Definitely, a labour of love to build. Put a proper earth on it and 
it'll be quite a nice instrument. Not sure I'd pay nearly a thousand 
pounds for it though.

Tony

www.oakleysound.com