Re: (idm) re: porter ricks...

From Lance C McGannon
Sent Fri, Mar 19th 1999, 18:00

At 12:49 AM 3/19/99 -0400, you wrote:
>> > 
>> > I couldnt disagree more with you Joshua. Chain
>> > Reaction is a groundbreaking dance music label.
>> > Chain Reaction, and it's earlier incarnation Basic
>> > Channel, are so influentional and original that
>> > they have founded their own genre of techno.
>> > Releases by Porter Ricks, Scion, Monolake,
>> > Various Artists, Vainqueur, and Substance are
>> > mainstays in the recordboxes of most of today's
>> > better djs. I can see since you favor the Thomas
>> > Koner solo stuff you probably like more ambient
>> > or experimental stuff. But to dismiss the label as
>> > a sub-par minimal house because the label doesnt
>> > release records in the style you like is just plain
>> > ignorant.
>
>lance,
>
>to disregard what i'm saying as my opinion is whats in your words
>ignorant. if i had no knowledge of the label, it would perhaps be so.
>however, it's my opinion, as i stated in my post. be it ground breaking
>or not, i still feel it's a mediocre label and i could easily back my
>opinion up, and perhaps i should have gone into more detail in my
>original post.
>
>i'm standing by what i said earlier and feel no need to defend it.
>i have no problem with your interestest and like of the label, but i'm
>offended at being called "ignorant" for thinking them mediocre. what's
>ground breaking to one, isn't for another.
>
>i'm not angry, and i hope this doesn't come across as hostile, but i
>feel i should stand up for myself.
>

hello joshua,
i'm not angered by your post in any way. I just 
couldnt fathom how one could reduce such an 
influential label to the description of bad minimal 
house - and i'm sure i'm not the only one who
thinks that. chain reaction and basic channel are
not just groundbreaking to me either - that status
is a widely held opinion, not just mine. so my
reply to you was not defending my personal
view, i was defending a commonly held view. 
again, no hard feelings, just differences in
opinion.

-->-Lance---
xxxxxxx@xxxx.xxx
xxxxx@xxxxxxxxx.xxx
p.o. box 450715
westlake, ohio 44145
united states